Small Arms Review
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Guns & Parts
    • Suppressors
    • Optics & Thermals
    • Ammunition
    • Gear
    • News & Opinion
    • Columns
    • Museums & Factory Tours
    • ID Guides
    • Interviews
    • Event Coverage
    • Articles by Issue
      • Volume 1
        • V1N1 (Oct 1997)
        • V1N2 (Nov 1997)
        • V1N3 (Dec 1997)
        • V1N4 (Jan 1998)
        • V1N5 (Feb 1998)
        • V1N6 (Mar 1998)
        • V1N7 (Apr 1998)
        • V1N8 (May 1998)
        • V1N9 (Jun 1998)
        • V1N10 (Jul 1998)
        • V1N11 (Aug 1998)
        • V1N12 (Sep 1998)
      • Volume 2
        • V2N1 (Oct 1998)
        • V2N2 (Nov 1998)
        • V2N3 (Dec 1998)
        • V2N4 (Jan 1999)
        • V2N5 (Feb 1999)
        • V2N6 (Mar 1999)
        • V2N7 (Apr 1999)
        • V2N8 (May 1999)
        • V2N9 (Jun 1999)
        • V2N10 (Jul 1999)
        • V2N11 (Aug 1999)
        • V2N12 (Sep 1999)
      • Volume 3
        • V3N1 (Oct 1999)
        • V3N2 (Nov 1999)
        • V3N3 (Dec 1999)
        • V3N4 (Jan 2000)
        • V3N5 (Feb 2000)
        • V3N6 (Mar 2000)
        • V3N7 (Apr 2000)
        • V3N8 (May 2000)
        • V3N9 (Jun 2000)
        • V3N10 (Jul 2000)
        • V3N11 (Aug 2000)
        • V3N12 (Sep 2000)
      • Volume 4
        • V4N1 (Oct 2000)
        • V4N2 (Nov 2000)
        • V4N3 (Dec 2000)
        • V4N4 (Jan 2001)
        • V4N5 (Feb 2001)
        • V4N6 (Mar 2001)
        • V4N7 (Apr 2001)
        • V4N8 (May 2001)
        • V4N9 (Jun 2001)
        • V4N10 (Jul 2001)
        • V4N11 (Aug 2001)
        • V4N12 (Sep 2001)
      • Volume 5
        • V5N1 (Oct 2001)
        • V5N2 (Nov 2001)
        • V5N3 (Dec 2001)
        • V5N4 (Jan 2002)
        • V5N5 (Feb 2002)
        • V5N6 (Mar 2002)
        • V5N7 (Apr 2002)
        • V5N8 (May 2002)
        • V5N9 (Jun 2002)
        • V5N10 (Jul 2002)
        • V5N11 (Aug 2002)
        • V5N12 (Sep 2002)
      • Volume 6
        • V6N1 (Oct 2002)
        • V6N2 (Nov 2002)
        • V6N3 (Dec 2002)
        • V6N4 (Jan 2003)
        • V6N5 (Feb 2003)
        • V6N6 (Mar 2003)
        • V6N7 (Apr 2003)
        • V6N8 (May 2003)
        • V6N9 (Jun 2003)
        • V6N10 (Jul 2003)
        • V6N11 (Aug 2003)
        • V6N12 (Sep 2003)
      • Volume 7
        • V7N1 (Oct 2003)
        • V7N2 (Nov 2003)
        • V7N3 (Dec 2003)
        • V7N4 (Jan 2004)
        • V7N5 (Feb 2004)
        • V7N6 (Mar 2004)
        • V7N7 (Apr 2004)
        • V7N8 (May 2004)
        • V7N9 (Jun 2004)
        • V7N10 (Jul 2004)
        • V7N11 (Aug 2004)
        • V7N12 (Sep 2004)
      • Volume 8
        • V8N1 (Oct 2004)
        • V8N2 (Nov 2004)
        • V8N3 (Dec 2004)
        • V8N4 (Jan 2005)
        • V8N5 (Feb 2005)
        • V8N6 (Mar 2005)
        • V8N7 (Apr 2005)
        • V8N8 (May 2005)
        • V8N9 (Jun 2005)
        • V8N10 (Jul 2005)
        • V8N11 (Aug 2005)
        • V8N12 (Sep 2005)
      • Volume 9
        • V9N1 (Oct 2005)
        • V9N2 (Nov 2005)
        • V9N3 (Dec 2005)
        • V9N4 (Jan 2006)
        • V9N5 (Feb 2006)
        • V9N6 (Mar 2006)
        • V9N7 (Apr 2006)
        • V9N8 (May 2006)
        • V9N9 (Jun 2006)
        • V9N10 (Jul 2006)
        • V9N11 (Aug 2006)
        • V9N12 (Sep 2006)
      • Volume 10
        • V10N1 (Oct 2006)
        • V10N2 (Nov 2006)
        • V10N3 (Dec 2006)
        • V10N4 (Jan 2007)
        • V10N5 (Feb 2007)
        • V10N6 (Mar 2007)
        • V10N7 (Apr 2007)
        • V10N8 (May 2007)
        • V10N9 (Jun 2007)
        • V10N10 (Jul 2007)
        • V10N11 (Aug 2007)
        • V10N12 (Sep 2007)
      • Volume 11
        • V11N1 (Oct 2007)
        • V11N2 (Nov 2007)
        • V11N3 (Dec 2007)
        • V11N4 (Jan 2008)
        • V11N5 (Feb 2008)
        • V11N6 (Mar 2008)
        • V11N7 (Apr 2008)
        • V11N8 (May 2008)
        • V11N9 (Jun 2008)
        • V11N10 (Jul 2008)
        • V11N11 (Aug 2008)
        • V11N12 (Sep 2008)
      • Volume 12
        • V12N1 (Oct 2008)
        • V12N2 (Nov 2008)
        • V12N3 (Dec 2008)
        • V12N4 (Jan 2009)
        • V12N5 (Feb 2009)
        • V12N6 (Mar 2009)
        • V12N7 (Apr 2009)
        • V12N8 (May 2009)
        • V12N9 (Jun 2009)
        • V12N10 (Jul 2009)
        • V12N11 (Aug 2009)
        • V12N12 (Sep 2009)
      • Volume 13
        • V13N1 (Oct 2009)
        • V13N2 (Nov 2009)
        • V13N3 (Dec 2009)
        • V13N4 (Jan 2010)
        • V13N5 (Feb 2010)
        • V13N6 (Mar 2010)
        • V13N7 (Apr 2010)
        • V13N8 (May 2010)
        • V13N9 (Jun 2010)
        • V13N10 (Jul 2010)
        • V13N11 (Aug 2010)
        • V13N12 (Sep 2010)
      • Volume 14
        • V14N1 (Oct 2010)
        • V14N2 (Nov 2010)
        • V14N3 (Dec 2010)
          • Ammunition
        • V14N4 (Jan 2011)
        • V14N5 (Feb 2011)
        • V14N6 (Mar 2011)
        • V14N7 (Apr 2011)
        • V14N8 (May 2011)
        • V14N9 (Jun 2011)
        • V14N10 (Jul 2011)
        • V14N11 (Aug 2011)
        • V14N12 (Sep 2011)
      • Volume 15
        • V15N1 (Oct 2011)
        • V15N2 (Nov 2011)
        • V15N4 (Jan 2012)
        • V15N5 (Feb 2012)
      • Volume 16
        • V16N1 (1st Quarter 2012)
        • V16N2 (2nd Quarter 2012)
        • V16N3 (3rd Quarter 2012)
        • V16N4 (4th Quarter 2012)
      • Volume 17
        • V17N1 (1st Quarter 2013)
        • V17N2 (2nd Quarter 2013)
        • V17N3 (3rd Quarter 2013)
        • V17N4 (4th Quarter 2013)
      • Volume 18
        • V18N1 (Jan Feb 2014)
        • V18N2 (Mar Apr 2014)
        • V18N3 (May Jun 2014)
        • V18N4 (Jul Aug 2014)
        • V18N5 (Sep Oct 2014)
        • V18N6 (Nov Dec 2014)
      • Volume 19
        • V19N1 (Jan 2015)
        • V19N2 (Feb Mar 2015)
        • V19N3 (Apr 2015)
        • V19N4 (May 2015)
        • V19N5 (Jun 2015)
        • V19N6 (Jul 2015)
        • V19N7 (Aug Sep 2015)
        • V19N8 (Oct 2015)
        • V19N9 (Nov 2015)
        • V19N10 (Dec 2015)
      • Volume 20
        • V20N1 (Jan 2016)
        • V20N2 (Feb Mar 2016)
        • V20N3 (Apr 2016)
        • V20N4 (May 2016)
        • V20N5 (Jun 2016)
        • V20N6 (Jul 2016)
        • V20N7 (Aug Sep 2016)
        • V20N8 (Oct 2016)
        • V20N9 (Nov 2016)
        • V20N10 (Dec 2016)
      • Volume 21
        • V21N1 (Jan 2017)
        • V21N2 (Feb Mar 2017)
        • V21N3 (Apr 2017)
        • V21N4 (May 2017)
        • V21N5 (Jun 2017)
        • V21N6 (Jul 2017)
        • V21N7 (Aug Sep 2017)
        • V21N8 (Oct 2017)
        • V21N9 (Nov 2017)
        • V21N10 (Dec 2017)
      • Volume 22
        • V22N1 (Jan 2018)
        • V22N2 (Feb 2018)
        • V22N3 (March 2018)
        • V22N4 (Apr 2018)
        • V22N5 (May 2018)
        • V22N6 (Jun Jul 2018)
        • V22N7 (Aug Sep 2018)
        • V22N8 (Oct 2018)
        • V22N9 (Nov 2018)
        • V22N10 (Dec 2018)
      • Volume 23
        • V23N1 (Jan 2019)
        • V23N2 (Feb 2019)
        • V23N3 (Mar 2019)
        • V23N4 (Apr 2019)
        • V23N5 (May 2019)
        • V23N6 (Jun Jul 2019)
        • V23N7 (Aug Sep 2019)
        • V23N8 (Oct 2019)
        • V23N9 (Nov 2019)
        • V23N10 (Dec 2019)
      • Volume 24
        • V24N1 (Jan 2020)
        • V24N2 (Feb 2020)
        • V24N3 (Mar 2020)
        • V24N4 (Apr 2020)
        • V24N5 (May 2020)
        • V24N6 (Jun Jul 2020)
        • V24N7 (Aug Sep 2020)
        • V24N8 (Oct 2020)
        • V24N9 (Nov 2020)
        • V24N10 (Dec 2020)
  • The Archive
    • Search The Archive
  • Store
    • Books
    • Back Issues
    • Merchandise
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Events
  • FrankenGun Challenge
  • About
    • About Small Arms Review
    • About Chipotle Publishing
    • Contact Us
    • Other Publications
      • Small Arms Defense Journal
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Guns & Parts
    • Suppressors
    • Optics & Thermals
    • Ammunition
    • Gear
    • News & Opinion
    • Columns
    • Museums & Factory Tours
    • ID Guides
    • Interviews
    • Event Coverage
    • Articles by Issue
      • Volume 1
        • V1N1 (Oct 1997)
        • V1N2 (Nov 1997)
        • V1N3 (Dec 1997)
        • V1N4 (Jan 1998)
        • V1N5 (Feb 1998)
        • V1N6 (Mar 1998)
        • V1N7 (Apr 1998)
        • V1N8 (May 1998)
        • V1N9 (Jun 1998)
        • V1N10 (Jul 1998)
        • V1N11 (Aug 1998)
        • V1N12 (Sep 1998)
      • Volume 2
        • V2N1 (Oct 1998)
        • V2N2 (Nov 1998)
        • V2N3 (Dec 1998)
        • V2N4 (Jan 1999)
        • V2N5 (Feb 1999)
        • V2N6 (Mar 1999)
        • V2N7 (Apr 1999)
        • V2N8 (May 1999)
        • V2N9 (Jun 1999)
        • V2N10 (Jul 1999)
        • V2N11 (Aug 1999)
        • V2N12 (Sep 1999)
      • Volume 3
        • V3N1 (Oct 1999)
        • V3N2 (Nov 1999)
        • V3N3 (Dec 1999)
        • V3N4 (Jan 2000)
        • V3N5 (Feb 2000)
        • V3N6 (Mar 2000)
        • V3N7 (Apr 2000)
        • V3N8 (May 2000)
        • V3N9 (Jun 2000)
        • V3N10 (Jul 2000)
        • V3N11 (Aug 2000)
        • V3N12 (Sep 2000)
      • Volume 4
        • V4N1 (Oct 2000)
        • V4N2 (Nov 2000)
        • V4N3 (Dec 2000)
        • V4N4 (Jan 2001)
        • V4N5 (Feb 2001)
        • V4N6 (Mar 2001)
        • V4N7 (Apr 2001)
        • V4N8 (May 2001)
        • V4N9 (Jun 2001)
        • V4N10 (Jul 2001)
        • V4N11 (Aug 2001)
        • V4N12 (Sep 2001)
      • Volume 5
        • V5N1 (Oct 2001)
        • V5N2 (Nov 2001)
        • V5N3 (Dec 2001)
        • V5N4 (Jan 2002)
        • V5N5 (Feb 2002)
        • V5N6 (Mar 2002)
        • V5N7 (Apr 2002)
        • V5N8 (May 2002)
        • V5N9 (Jun 2002)
        • V5N10 (Jul 2002)
        • V5N11 (Aug 2002)
        • V5N12 (Sep 2002)
      • Volume 6
        • V6N1 (Oct 2002)
        • V6N2 (Nov 2002)
        • V6N3 (Dec 2002)
        • V6N4 (Jan 2003)
        • V6N5 (Feb 2003)
        • V6N6 (Mar 2003)
        • V6N7 (Apr 2003)
        • V6N8 (May 2003)
        • V6N9 (Jun 2003)
        • V6N10 (Jul 2003)
        • V6N11 (Aug 2003)
        • V6N12 (Sep 2003)
      • Volume 7
        • V7N1 (Oct 2003)
        • V7N2 (Nov 2003)
        • V7N3 (Dec 2003)
        • V7N4 (Jan 2004)
        • V7N5 (Feb 2004)
        • V7N6 (Mar 2004)
        • V7N7 (Apr 2004)
        • V7N8 (May 2004)
        • V7N9 (Jun 2004)
        • V7N10 (Jul 2004)
        • V7N11 (Aug 2004)
        • V7N12 (Sep 2004)
      • Volume 8
        • V8N1 (Oct 2004)
        • V8N2 (Nov 2004)
        • V8N3 (Dec 2004)
        • V8N4 (Jan 2005)
        • V8N5 (Feb 2005)
        • V8N6 (Mar 2005)
        • V8N7 (Apr 2005)
        • V8N8 (May 2005)
        • V8N9 (Jun 2005)
        • V8N10 (Jul 2005)
        • V8N11 (Aug 2005)
        • V8N12 (Sep 2005)
      • Volume 9
        • V9N1 (Oct 2005)
        • V9N2 (Nov 2005)
        • V9N3 (Dec 2005)
        • V9N4 (Jan 2006)
        • V9N5 (Feb 2006)
        • V9N6 (Mar 2006)
        • V9N7 (Apr 2006)
        • V9N8 (May 2006)
        • V9N9 (Jun 2006)
        • V9N10 (Jul 2006)
        • V9N11 (Aug 2006)
        • V9N12 (Sep 2006)
      • Volume 10
        • V10N1 (Oct 2006)
        • V10N2 (Nov 2006)
        • V10N3 (Dec 2006)
        • V10N4 (Jan 2007)
        • V10N5 (Feb 2007)
        • V10N6 (Mar 2007)
        • V10N7 (Apr 2007)
        • V10N8 (May 2007)
        • V10N9 (Jun 2007)
        • V10N10 (Jul 2007)
        • V10N11 (Aug 2007)
        • V10N12 (Sep 2007)
      • Volume 11
        • V11N1 (Oct 2007)
        • V11N2 (Nov 2007)
        • V11N3 (Dec 2007)
        • V11N4 (Jan 2008)
        • V11N5 (Feb 2008)
        • V11N6 (Mar 2008)
        • V11N7 (Apr 2008)
        • V11N8 (May 2008)
        • V11N9 (Jun 2008)
        • V11N10 (Jul 2008)
        • V11N11 (Aug 2008)
        • V11N12 (Sep 2008)
      • Volume 12
        • V12N1 (Oct 2008)
        • V12N2 (Nov 2008)
        • V12N3 (Dec 2008)
        • V12N4 (Jan 2009)
        • V12N5 (Feb 2009)
        • V12N6 (Mar 2009)
        • V12N7 (Apr 2009)
        • V12N8 (May 2009)
        • V12N9 (Jun 2009)
        • V12N10 (Jul 2009)
        • V12N11 (Aug 2009)
        • V12N12 (Sep 2009)
      • Volume 13
        • V13N1 (Oct 2009)
        • V13N2 (Nov 2009)
        • V13N3 (Dec 2009)
        • V13N4 (Jan 2010)
        • V13N5 (Feb 2010)
        • V13N6 (Mar 2010)
        • V13N7 (Apr 2010)
        • V13N8 (May 2010)
        • V13N9 (Jun 2010)
        • V13N10 (Jul 2010)
        • V13N11 (Aug 2010)
        • V13N12 (Sep 2010)
      • Volume 14
        • V14N1 (Oct 2010)
        • V14N2 (Nov 2010)
        • V14N3 (Dec 2010)
          • Ammunition
        • V14N4 (Jan 2011)
        • V14N5 (Feb 2011)
        • V14N6 (Mar 2011)
        • V14N7 (Apr 2011)
        • V14N8 (May 2011)
        • V14N9 (Jun 2011)
        • V14N10 (Jul 2011)
        • V14N11 (Aug 2011)
        • V14N12 (Sep 2011)
      • Volume 15
        • V15N1 (Oct 2011)
        • V15N2 (Nov 2011)
        • V15N4 (Jan 2012)
        • V15N5 (Feb 2012)
      • Volume 16
        • V16N1 (1st Quarter 2012)
        • V16N2 (2nd Quarter 2012)
        • V16N3 (3rd Quarter 2012)
        • V16N4 (4th Quarter 2012)
      • Volume 17
        • V17N1 (1st Quarter 2013)
        • V17N2 (2nd Quarter 2013)
        • V17N3 (3rd Quarter 2013)
        • V17N4 (4th Quarter 2013)
      • Volume 18
        • V18N1 (Jan Feb 2014)
        • V18N2 (Mar Apr 2014)
        • V18N3 (May Jun 2014)
        • V18N4 (Jul Aug 2014)
        • V18N5 (Sep Oct 2014)
        • V18N6 (Nov Dec 2014)
      • Volume 19
        • V19N1 (Jan 2015)
        • V19N2 (Feb Mar 2015)
        • V19N3 (Apr 2015)
        • V19N4 (May 2015)
        • V19N5 (Jun 2015)
        • V19N6 (Jul 2015)
        • V19N7 (Aug Sep 2015)
        • V19N8 (Oct 2015)
        • V19N9 (Nov 2015)
        • V19N10 (Dec 2015)
      • Volume 20
        • V20N1 (Jan 2016)
        • V20N2 (Feb Mar 2016)
        • V20N3 (Apr 2016)
        • V20N4 (May 2016)
        • V20N5 (Jun 2016)
        • V20N6 (Jul 2016)
        • V20N7 (Aug Sep 2016)
        • V20N8 (Oct 2016)
        • V20N9 (Nov 2016)
        • V20N10 (Dec 2016)
      • Volume 21
        • V21N1 (Jan 2017)
        • V21N2 (Feb Mar 2017)
        • V21N3 (Apr 2017)
        • V21N4 (May 2017)
        • V21N5 (Jun 2017)
        • V21N6 (Jul 2017)
        • V21N7 (Aug Sep 2017)
        • V21N8 (Oct 2017)
        • V21N9 (Nov 2017)
        • V21N10 (Dec 2017)
      • Volume 22
        • V22N1 (Jan 2018)
        • V22N2 (Feb 2018)
        • V22N3 (March 2018)
        • V22N4 (Apr 2018)
        • V22N5 (May 2018)
        • V22N6 (Jun Jul 2018)
        • V22N7 (Aug Sep 2018)
        • V22N8 (Oct 2018)
        • V22N9 (Nov 2018)
        • V22N10 (Dec 2018)
      • Volume 23
        • V23N1 (Jan 2019)
        • V23N2 (Feb 2019)
        • V23N3 (Mar 2019)
        • V23N4 (Apr 2019)
        • V23N5 (May 2019)
        • V23N6 (Jun Jul 2019)
        • V23N7 (Aug Sep 2019)
        • V23N8 (Oct 2019)
        • V23N9 (Nov 2019)
        • V23N10 (Dec 2019)
      • Volume 24
        • V24N1 (Jan 2020)
        • V24N2 (Feb 2020)
        • V24N3 (Mar 2020)
        • V24N4 (Apr 2020)
        • V24N5 (May 2020)
        • V24N6 (Jun Jul 2020)
        • V24N7 (Aug Sep 2020)
        • V24N8 (Oct 2020)
        • V24N9 (Nov 2020)
        • V24N10 (Dec 2020)
  • The Archive
    • Search The Archive
  • Store
    • Books
    • Back Issues
    • Merchandise
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Events
  • FrankenGun Challenge
  • About
    • About Small Arms Review
    • About Chipotle Publishing
    • Contact Us
    • Other Publications
      • Small Arms Defense Journal
No Result
View All Result
Small Arms Review
No Result
View All Result
Home Articles Ammunition

Read Your Magazines

SAR Staff by SAR Staff
October 20, 2022
in Ammunition, Articles, Articles by Issue, Guns & Parts, Search by Issue, V20N10 (Dec 2016), Volume 20
Read Your Magazines
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Paul Evancoe

Many believe a repeating firearm’s reliability is based upon its operating system. While this assumption is true, the root cause of most weapons’ malfunctions center upon a failure to properly feed live rounds, or properly eject spent brass. A clean properly lubricated operating system is important, but the vast majority of malfunctions can be ultimately attributed to some form of magazine failure. This is true for all repeating actions from manually operated bolt and lever actions, to self-loading semi-automatic and automatic actions. Jams, stovepipes and ejection failures top the malfunction list; but first, some design success stories.

Mikhail Kalashnikov developed the AK-47 in the 1940s for the Soviet Red Army. Since then, over 75 million AKs have been made. Its short stoke gas piston operating system is fed by a robust double stack 30 round all steel magazine. The AK-47 is not a precision made elegant weapon, but it’s cheap to manufacture and is perhaps the most reliable and proliferate assault rifle ever made.

In 1948 Major Uziel Gal developed his easy and cheap method to manufacture a highly reliable Uzi 9mm submachine gun that employs a simple blowback operating system fed by a sturdy 25- or 32- round double stack magazine. More than 10 million Uzi sub-guns have since been manufactured. Uziel Gal’s design philosophy, according to him, was to first design the magazine around a particular round of choice (he chose the 9mm Parabellum). Then design the gun around the magazine. This, he insisted, “provides for the utmost performance reliability.”

Picture shows a number of different magazines discussed in the body of the article. Might make a good first picture on article title page.

This same design philosophy was used on a grander scale in the 1960s in the USAF’s wildly successful close air support A-10 Warthog.

The operational requirement was for an aircraft that could successfully take out tanks and armored vehicles, and provide close air support for ground troop operations, e.g., stop the Soviet advance across the “Plains of Europe.” This requirement translated to a comparatively low cost aircraft with high target lethality and superior survivability against ground fire. The desig ners began by selecting the armor-killing gun; a single 30 mm GAU-8/A seven-barrel Gatling gun. Then they built a survivable aircraft around the gun, with a unique titanium bathtub-like armor shield surrounding the lower cockpit to protect the pilot from ground fire.

Double Stack

Their design choice of materials and functional simplicity provides for a highly reliable combat pistol that feeds flawlessly when shooting in any attitude (vertically up or down, or on either side ejection port up or down, with or without the additional weight of a sound suppressor).

More recently, this design philosophy was employed by FN when they designed their polymer lower and stainless steel upper FNP-45 (now the FNX-45). The pistol’s high capacity 45 ACP double stack stainless steel magazines
contain beautifully designed followers lifted by a coiled wire spring.

Magazines Are Fundamental to Operating System Reliability

There are several very important firearm design features that should be fully understood before making any firearms purchase. The single most important feature, and also most often overlooked, is the magazine. Magazines come in a variety of forms. The classic removable box-type design used for most modern assault rifles and pistols is most common. Additionally, there are tubular magazines mounted beneath the barrel (or inside the stock) like many lever action and pump action rifles and shotguns employ, and internal small capacity magazines commonly used on many bolt action hunting rifles. There are also rotary magazines and externally mounted high capacity drum and box magazines that contain linked ammunition belts used on most all machineguns. Linked ammunition magazines and their associated feed conduit will not be addressed in this discussion.

Regardless of design, magazines provide for ammunition storage and share a common operating design in all repeating actions by presenting the next round to the bolt’s forward stroke for chambering. Magazines may appear to possess little sophistication, and indeed some do not. After all, in most cases they’re little more than a spring, a follower, a floor plate and a plastic or fabricated sheet metal container; pretty basic engineering – right?

Different AR-15 style 30 round magazines. P-mag Gen II polymer †is center.

The truth is, most magazines are far more sophisticated. Here’s the operating process in simple terms. When the gun is fired and the spent round is ejected on the bolt’s back stroke, the magazine spring pushes the follower upward and the next round is presented at exactly the right height and angle of attack so the bolt’s forward stroke can skim the round off the top of the stack and carry (feed) it into the gun’s chamber. Seems simple enough – what can go wrong?

Most of us would like to think that factory magazines are built to a precision specification designed for each particular gun model, and that magazines are fully interchangeable within the same gun model. While that is fundamentally true, not all magazines are created equal. Different manufacturers’ quality control their products to different plus/minus tolerances. For example, the gun’s bolt and/or slide is fitted to the upper and/or receiver along with the trigger group. The barrel is fitted to the gun with particular attention to head space (gap between the bolt face and chamber) when the gun is loaded, in-battery and ready to fire. Attention to detail is given to material construction, tolerances and finish on these parts, because they must work together smoothly if the gun is to have any operating system reliability.

This translates to a variety of different parts with different tolerances, some plus, some minus, being combined to work within an overall design specification. It also means for example, if several plus tolerance parts are combined with other plus tolerance parts this can mean a tight fit. The reverse is true for the combination of minus parts resulting in a loose fit. As long as the overall factory tolerance specification is met, the combination should reliably function as designed. However, aftermarket parts are not factory parts and don’t undergo factory quality assurance, and that is most often a problem. This is especially true in aftermarket magazines.

Even with reasonable design and manufacturing quality assurance of critical gun parts, expensive guns still often experience out of the box feed, extraction and ejection malfunctions, leaving the shooter scratching his head and wondering why. Not generally understood, the reason is usually the magazine. Unfortunately, far less manufacturing attention is paid to magazine design, material construction, and fit.

Old style Vietnam vintage AR magazine. Aluminum construction, removable floor plate, single wire spring. Most of today’s magazines have multi-strand twisted spring wires to prevent compression “memory.”

Let’s look at the dynamics at work inside a magazine. The follower is pushed upward by the magazine spring, elevating the cartridge stack holding it in tension against the magazine’s feed lips. The spring must have enough consistent tension to overcome both the weight of the cartridge stack and the drag (friction) of the follower as it climbs the magazine walls. It must also do this in a proper time to present the cartridge for feeding when needed- if it’s dragging a little, the bolt might be coming forward and miss the feed. The greater the capacity of the magazine, the “more powerful” the spring must be to do its job. Then add some grit inside the magazine or rusty or corroded inside walls and you have a feed malfunction. The root cause is because the spring can no longer reliably elevate the follower and elevate/hold the cartridge stack in the ready position against the feed lips.

In order to understand what to look for we need to take a close look at the variables involved, beginning with a common box-type removable magazine. Many of us believe if a 20 round magazine is good, then a 30 round is better, so a 40 round magazine is better still. Nothing could be farther from the truth. In reality, the higher the magazine capacity, the greater chance of malfunction. Why? With more rounds comes more weight in the cartridge stack, more drag/friction for the magazine spring to overcome, more cartridge alignment problems, etc.

Box-type magazines are installed into the magazine well by pushing them (or jamming them) upward until the magazine catch engages a hole or slot cut into the magazine body for that purpose. This catch holds the magazine from being inserted too far and also holds it in place until the magazine release button is pushed. This releases the magazine, allowing it to either fall from the gun under its own weight or pulled from the gun with a free hand.

In most gun designs, the magazine catch is insufficiently robust. It is usually a pressed or sintered part (not precision machined and tempered) that uses a small spring to keep it extended (locked) into the magazine catch hole/slot. In most designs, little importance is placed on the robustness of the magazine catch’s axel, spring or material construction. Sand can easily foul the catch’s proper locking movement, the spring can fatigue or break, and the catch itself can wear down. This results in catch failure and a gun that will not reliably hold the weight of a loaded magazine. The higher the magazine capacity, the greater the weight that small catch must hold.

Ambidextrous magazine releases require special attention because they are often poorly designed and not robust enough to hold the weight of a loaded 30 or 40 round magazine in the magazine well. Consider the weight of a 30 or 40 round magazine hanging on that small catch. Now add some tactical scenario rough treatment like banging the installed magazine down on a hard surface. Forces are applied in sheer and that small catch is exposed to tremendous loads. Obviously, if you’re a fair weather shooter who doesn’t expose his gun to combat-like operating extremes, reliability may not mean much. But if your gun’s reliability means life and death, pay attention. You may want to upgrade your magazine catch and spring.

n improper angle of attack will result in a failure to feed, failure to eject and stovepipe malfunctions.†

Improper Magazine Fit is a Feed Malfunction Root Cause

Your magazines’ installed height is critically important. When the magazine installs too low, the round is presented too low to the bolt face on the forward stroke and at the wrong angle. This situation many times causes stove pipe-type malfunctions on the forward stroke, or being missed by the bolt altogether (the bolt passes above the cartridge missing it on the forward stroke).

Again a loose fitting magazine can be the result of wear or it’s just out of spec. A magazine’s installed height is one of the most important factors in reliability. Magazines that don’t feed properly should be discarded whether they’re out of the box new or well used.

A second thing to look for is fully loaded magazines that fit too tightly in the magazine well. This is especially true in pistols. Tight fit results from either poor magazine material construction, sloppy tolerances in manufacturing, or from magazine swell. Magazine swell is often the result of magazine walls constructed from plastic or sheet metal that is too flimsy and flexible. The symptom to watch for is when the cartridges of a fully loaded magazine push the magazine walls outward, swelling it to a tight fit against the gun’s magazine well. This is a malfunction waiting to happen.

Also, the magazines themselves can be made flimsily to the point that the magazine catch doesn’t adequately engage the slot intended for it, or the slot becomes easily dented or worn as a result of poor magazine material construction. Many (not all) aluminum and plastic magazines are notorious for this type of failure. There are some exceptionally reliable polymer magazines on the market. For example, P-Mag makes an extremely reliable polymer magazine as does Glock with their unique polymer-sheathed metal body magazines.

1911 magazines made by different manufacturers. Note the difference in followers and feed lips design.

Follower design, material construction and alignment with the magazine walls is another critical magazine reliability element. Think of the follower in terms of it being an elevator that lifts the cartridge column upward. Followers come in many forms, polymer, composite and metal. Some are molded, some are cast and some are fabricated from sheet metal. All serve the same function and that is to provide a stable base on which the cartridge stack rests. The magazine’s spring beneath the follower applies tensioned pressure to consistently push up the cartridge stack against the magazine lips, presenting the next cartridge to the bolt on its forward stroke. The spring tension pushing against the follower must not be too powerful or the cartridges won’t feed. It cannot be too weak or the rounds will fall out of the magazine when the action is open.

Regularly clean and lubricate the inside of your magazines. Where design permits, disassemble your magazines by removing the floor plate (Only if designed for removal – many floor plates are permanently attached). Pull the spring and follower out and clean all the parts as well as the inside of the magazine. If you find rust or corrosion that cannot be removed, throw the magazine away. Lightly lubricate the parts and ensure proper reassembly. In magazines that have welded floor plates that can’t be removed, soak the magazine in gun cleaning solvent. Blow it out with compressed air. Apply a dry lubricant to the internal walls, spring and follower. Dry lube works best because sand and dirt usually stick to a wet lubricant. After cleaning, compress the follower using your finger or dowel. Ensure it functions properly and doesn’t scrape or drag along its travel. Ensure the floor plate is engaged so your magazine won’t inadvertently come apart, spilling its rounds in the middle of a gunfight.

Last, carefully inspect the magazine’s feed lips for alignment. The feed lips can often become bent and misaligned from dropping the empty magazine on the ground during a tactical reload of your gun. Misaligned feed lips will result in feed malfunctions. Damaged feed lips can sometime be realigned by skillfully bending them back into tolerance. However, that is usually a trial and error (hit or miss) process not recommended for magazines intended for tactical use. Also inspect the magazine body for cracks that can affect structural integrity. Even small cracks can cause malfunctions or lead to them. Discard those magazines.

Most pump actions and lever actions use a tubular magazine that is mounted beneath the barrel or contained within the stock. Tubular magazines suffer some of the same internal malfunction issues inherent to box magazines, but have a distinctly different feed process than box magazines. The internal cleanliness of a tubular magazine is extremely important to its reliability. Internal dirt and rust both inside the magazine tube and inside the follower rod containing the follower spring, are usually the show stoppers. The tubular magazine housing along with the follower rod and spring should both be internally cleaned and lubricated with a dry lubricant. This will reduce cartridge drag when fully loaded and is especially important to reliable feed when shooting vertically – up or down.

A second critically important feature on guns with tubular magazines is the feed mechanism located beneath the bolt that lifts/elevates a round from the tubular magazine upward, presenting it at precisely the right angle of attack to the bolt’s forward stroke for chambering. That feed mechanism, in cheaper guns is many times poorly constructed (sometimes from polymer materials). Wear and dirt will cause the feed mechanism to become sloppy (out of tolerance) or prevent it from full travel resulting improper feed.

AR style magazines from different manufacturers. Notice the difference in floor plates.

What about drum magazines? Guns that are factory-designed for drum magazines like the Thompson sub-machinegun, have robust magazine catches intended to hold the added weight of a loaded drum magazine. Using an aftermarket drum magazine in an AR-style gun or pistol without replacing the gun’s magazine catch with a significantly more robust version, is suicidal in a gunfight. The same goes for extra high capacity magazines that extend well beneath the magazine well. You’re asking for feed and ejection malfunctions for all the reasons previously discussed.

Finally, the magazine’s spring is a critical element of reliability for all magazines no matter what type. Early magazine designs employed leaf-style flat springs or single strand spring wire that when kept compressed in a full magazine for months on end would not reliably spring back (and reliably feed the contents of the entire magazine). This is known as “spring memory.” Early AR magazines (Vietnam vintage) and Model 1911 pistol magazines were like that. Magazines with flat springs or single strand spring wire required unloading about every two weeks with a couple of weeks “rest” before reloading so the spring wouldn’t “remember” its compression. Many shooters still abide by that today and religiously rotate their loaded and unloaded ready magazines to prevent magazine compression spring memory.

However, most quality magazine springs today are made from multi-strand twisted steel spring wire alloyed specifically for that purpose. They don’t have a memory and can remain loaded for years without spring memory becoming a reliability factor. It is nevertheless important to ensure the springs in your magazines are of the quality variety. Check them and be sure. Magazine springs and their unique metallurgy will be the topic of a future article.

So now you have it. Use only quality factory design spec magazines. Check each magazine for proper installed height. Ensure the magazine spring and follower align the rounds with the feed lips. Ensure the feed lips are undamaged and aligned. Inspect the magazine body for cracks. Keep the inside of the magazine clean and lubricated. Ensure the floor plate is firmly in place. Inspect the gun’s magazine release mechanism for wear and proper operation. Keep it clean and lubricated. Discard magazines that are ill fitting, damaged, or that continually cause gun malfunction. Read your magazines.

This article first appeared in Small Arms Review V20N10 (December 2016)
Tags: 2016DECEMBER 2016Paul EvancoeRead Your MagazinesV20N10
Previous Post

Legally Armed: November 2016

Next Post

NFATCA Report: V21N1

Next Post
NFATCA Report: V19N1

NFATCA Report: V21N1

TRENDING STORIES

  • U.S. NAVY MK18 MOD O CUSTOM CLOSE QUARTER COMBAT WEAPON FOR THE SEAFARING SERVICE

    U.S. NAVY MK18 MOD O CUSTOM CLOSE QUARTER COMBAT WEAPON FOR THE SEAFARING SERVICE

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Recreational Use Of 40MM Grenade Launchers

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Customizing the Already Custom SIG P320 Spectre Comp

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Col. Rex Applegate: The Knife Designs of a Close-Combat Legend

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Firearm Review: Pioneer Arms Classic AK in 7.62×39

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
U.S. NAVY MK18 MOD O CUSTOM CLOSE QUARTER COMBAT WEAPON FOR THE SEAFARING SERVICE

U.S. NAVY MK18 MOD O CUSTOM CLOSE QUARTER COMBAT WEAPON FOR THE SEAFARING SERVICE

Recreational Use Of 40MM Grenade Launchers

Recreational Use Of 40MM Grenade Launchers

SIG Spectre Comp with AXG Grip Module

Customizing the Already Custom SIG P320 Spectre Comp

Col. Rex Applegate: The Knife Designs of a Close-Combat Legend

Col. Rex Applegate: The Knife Designs of a Close-Combat Legend

New Review: V19N1

New Review: V23N3

SAR|Special

SAR|Special

The Grand Power Q100

The Grand Power Q100

A Fading Star: The star S135 Submachine Gun, That is

A Fading Star: The star S135 Submachine Gun, That is

The Luger Rifle

Where in the world is the Luger rifle?

Book Reviews: September 2016

BOOK REVIEW: Two Great MP40 Books 

Henk Visser Interview: SAR Talks Stoners, CETME, HK with One of the Founders of the Modern Small Arms Industry

Henk Visser Interview: SAR Talks Stoners, CETME, HK with One of the Founders of the Modern Small Arms Industry

The SCCY DVG-1—The Changer of Games

The SCCY DVG-1—The Changer of Games

QUICK LINKS

  • About Chipotle Publishing
  • About Small Arms Review
  • Advertise with Us
  • Write for Us

CONTACT DETAILS

  • Phone: +1 (702) 565-0746
  • E-mail: office@smallarmsreview.com
  • Web: www.chipotlepublishing.com
  • Chipotle Publishing, LLC 631 N. Stephanie St., No. 282, Henderson, NV 89014
Small Arms Review

FOLLOW US

  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer

© 2022 Chipotle Publishing | All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Guns & Parts
    • Suppressors
    • Optics & Thermals
    • Ammunition
    • Gear
    • News & Opinion
    • Columns
    • Museums & Factory Tours
    • ID Guides
    • Interviews
    • Event Coverage
    • Articles by Issue
      • Volume 1
      • Volume 2
      • Volume 3
      • Volume 4
      • Volume 5
      • Volume 6
      • Volume 7
      • Volume 8
      • Volume 9
      • Volume 10
      • Volume 11
      • Volume 12
      • Volume 13
      • Volume 14
      • Volume 15
      • Volume 16
      • Volume 17
      • Volume 18
      • Volume 19
      • Volume 20
      • Volume 21
      • Volume 22
      • Volume 23
      • Volume 24
  • The Archive
    • Search The Archive
  • Store
    • Books
    • Back Issues
    • Merchandise
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Events
  • FrankenGun Challenge
  • About
    • About Small Arms Review
    • About Chipotle Publishing
    • Contact Us
    • Other Publications
      • Small Arms Defense Journal

© 2022 Chipotle Publishing | All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.

Subscribe To Our Weekly Newsletter

Are you in the know?
Stay up to date with the latest articles.

Facebook-f Linkedin Instagram

Redirecting to External Website

You are leaving the Small Arms Review website and will be redirected to an external link in a 5 Seconds.
VISIT NOW!